We Are Here To Serve You

insurance brokers fort myers

When we opened our doors in 1974, we made a commitment to provide our neighbors and local businesses with the quality and professional service that they deserve along with competitive, comprehensive insurance programs designed to protect them, their property, businesses, and loved ones against unforeseen loss and damage. For nearly 40 years and counting, Fort Myers, Florida-based Herndon Carr & Co has kept that commitment.

As an Independent Insurance agency, we represent a wide variety of insurance products to meet your needs.  If you need homeowners or condominium insurance or insurance for your investment property, we write policies throughout Bonita Springs, Cape Coral, Estero, Fort Myers, Naples, Punta Gorda, and Port Charlotte that are designed to meet your needs and protect the nest you’ve created.  With insurance programs specially suited to our high net worth clients, we are able to create custom package policies designed for your specific coverage needs.

Also, whether you’re getting your first new car, upgrading to a new model, trading in for a family vehicle, or enjoying the freedom of the road that comes with retirement, we can provide you with Auto insurance plans that fit your specific needs and budget.

What’s more, our full suite of personal insurance coverages includes coverage for boats, RVs, motorcycles, valuables, and much more, including protection against flood and windstorm damage.

Businesses throughout the area also look to Herndon Carr & Co to protect their assets, properties, management, employees, and much more. We offer a wide range of business insurance solutions – from Liability coverages to Property insurance, Business Interruption, Workers Compensation, Surety Bonds, and much more. Additionally, the same businesses that trust us to provide sound, competitive insurance plans also come to us to help them with their Employee Benefits needs.

Integrity has been the cornerstone in the relationships we have maintained throughout the years, not only with our clients but also with the many companies we represent. We invite you to take the time to speak with us, meet our staff, and experience the Herndon Carr difference. Call us at (239) 939-1996 or (800-998-7551).

Independent Insurance Agent
Indepentant Insurance Agent home

Insurance Companies We Represent